Before Initiating Your Submission
Before submitting your work, please ensure the following:
1. Journal Scope Alignment
Verify that your manuscript aligns with the Aims & Scope of Acta Electronica Sinica to confirm suitability for publication.
2. Content Type Compliance
Confirm your manuscript matches one of our accepted content types, as specified in:ABOUT-About Information Frontiers-Content Types
3. Policy Review
Carefully review all journal policies prior to submission to ensure full compliance.
Preparing Your Manuscript
All submissions must be prepared using the Acta Electronica Sinica Manuscript Template in either Microsoft Word (.docx) format or Microsoft Word 97-2003 (.doc) format. Using our official template ensures proper formatting and facilitates efficient processing.
The following items must be included in the body of the manuscripts.
— Title
— Abstract
— Keywords
— Main Text
— References
— Appendixes (if applicable)
— Conflict of Interest (if applicable)
To maintain our double-blind peer review process:
— Remove ALL author-identifying information from the manuscript file
— Submit author details (names, affiliations, funding information, biographies) separately through the online submission system
— Ensure no acknowledgments appear in the main text
To ensure smooth processing of your manuscript, please prepare the following items for submission:
1. Manuscript Files
— PDF File: A PDF version converted from your Microsoft Word document.
— Source File: The original editable file in Microsoft Word format (.docx or .doc). For references, initial submissions may use any consistent citation style. Upon provisional acceptance, references must be reformatted to comply with GB/T 7714-2015 standards.
2. License to Publish
Download and complete the License to Publish Form.
Signed copies (electronic signatures accepted) must be submitted with your manuscript.
3. Cover Letter (Recommended)
A well-crafted cover letter are recommended to submit accompany your submission and include:
— Names, email addresses, and ORCID IDs for all authors, including the selection of one to be the corresponding author.
— The title of the paper and a summary of the main point (research background, main achievements, theoretical innovations, application background, and fields the readers are involved in, etc.)
— A clear statement explaining the technical extensions beyond the original proceedings paper if the manuscript is an extended version of a conference paper.
4. Suggested Reviewers
Authors could proviede names, institutional affiliations, and email addresses for the potential referees.
5. PDF Copy of the Conference Paper (if applicable)
For manuscripts that represent extended versions of previously published conference papers, please include:
— A complete PDF copy of the original proceedings paper
— A brief statement in the cover letter highlighting the conference where it was originally presented and substantive new content/improvements in the extended version.
This helps editors and reviewers properly evaluate the manuscript's novel contributions. (Note: Failure to provide this documentation may delay the review process.)
Submitting Your Manuscript
Upon successful submission through our online system, an automatic confirmation email will be sent to all the author(s). Email submissions are not accepted.
The submitting/corresponding author must log in the system using an existing account, or register using their ORCID iD. All authors are strongly encouraged to create accounts in the system in advance. If co-authors lack accounts, the submitting/corresponding author must create profiles for them during submission. This ensures proper attribution and communication throughout the review process
Revising Your Manuscript
Authors must submit a detailed point-by-point response addressing all reviewers' comments included in the decision letter. The response may be provided either as a separate section within the revised manuscript submission, or inn a dedicated attachment file.
Reviewer responses will typically be shared with the original reviewers during subsequent rounds of review. For any confidential remarks not intended for reviewers, please clearly mark as "For Editor's Eyes Only" and include these comments in a separate letter addressed specifically to the editor.
Acta Electronica Sinica operates under the double-blind peer review process, where reviewers are unaware of the authors’ identities, and authors do not know who the reviewers or editors are. Reviewers also remain anonymous to each other.
The figure below illustrates the peer review process for manuscripts submitted to Acta Electronica Sinica.

Upon submission, your manuscript will undergo the following peer review process:
1. Initial Screening: The editorial office staff verifies the manuscript and supplementary materials for completeness and adherence to journal standards.
2. Editorial Assignment: The Editor-in-Chief (EIC) conducts an initial assessment of the manuscript to determine its suitability for further consideration. If deemed appropriate, the EIC assigns the manuscript to an Area Editor, who then evaluates whether it meets the journal's criteria for peer review.
3. Associate Editor Assignment: The manuscript is then assigned to an Associate Editor (AE) who will oversee the review process.
4. Review Coordination: The AE identifies and invites appropriate reviewers for the manuscript.
5. Peer Evaluation: Selected reviewers critically assess the manuscript and submit detailed evaluations.
6. AE Decision/Recommendation: Based on reviewers’ comments, the AE provides one of the following decisions/recommendations: (1) Request revisions (with specific guidance for improvement); (2) Rejection; (3) Propose acceptance (subject to EIC approval).
7. Area Editor Decision/Recommendation: The Area Editor reviews all evaluations from reviewers and the AE and makes one of the following decisions/recommendations: (1) Request revisions (with specific guidance for improvement); (2) Rejection; (3) Propose acceptance (subject to EIC approval).
8. Editorial Decision: The EIC makes the ultimate publication decision and communicates this to the corresponding author.
9. Next Steps: If accepted with revisions, authors will receive specific feedback and be invited to resubmit an revised version.
1 Quality and plagiarism check
Our editorial team will:
— Confirm receipt of all required documents and infromation (please refer to our Submission Guidelines)
— Conduct plagiarism checks using CNKI, WANFANG, and iThenticate
2 – 3 First editorial decision
After initial checks, the manuscript is assigned to the EIC, who then assigns it to an area editor. Both of the EIC and the area editor review the paper and determine whether it should proceed to peer review. The area editor’s decision is based on:
— the degree to which the manuscript advances the covering research field
— the soundness of its conclusions
— the strength of the supporting evidence (including data and analyses)
— the broad relevance of the findings to the journal’s audience.
4 – 6 Peer review
If the EIC or Area Editor approves the manuscript for peer review, it will be assigned to an AE to oversee the evaluation process. The AE will identify and invite qualified experts in the relevant field to review the submission. Reviewer selection is a crucial component of our editorial process, and we carefully consider the need for comprehensive coverage of both technical and conceptual aspects of the work. While authors may suggest potential reviewers (which we welcome as helpful input), the AE makes the final selection. All reviews are conducted under strict confidentiality, with reviewers' identities protected throughout the process.
7 – 8 Editorial decision
Following receipt of all reviewers’ comments, the editorial team (Associate Editor, Area Editor, and Editor-in-Chief) will carefully evaluate the feedback and reach a decision. While the Associate Editor and Area Editor may recommend revisions or rejection, only the Editor-in-Chief (EIC) holds the authority to make the final acceptance decision.
— Acceptance with Revisions: The manuscript is accepted for publication pending formatting revisions to comply with journal standards. Note: The journal reserves the right to withdraw acceptance if ethical concerns are identified during the editing process.
— Revise and Resubmit: Authors are invited to address specific concerns raised by reviewers and editors before reconsideration for publication.
— Rejection: The manuscript is declined, typically due to: Insufficient evidence supporting the conclusions; Limited novelty or significance relative to the journal's standards; Fundamental methodological flaws identified during review.
9 Revise and resubmit
If your manuscript receives a "Revise and Resubmit" decision, please carefully follow the editorial instructions provided in the decision letter. Your resubmission must include:
— Revised Manuscript: Incorporate all necessary revisions addressing both editorial and peer review comments; Highlight changes in the text (e.g., using track changes or colored text)
— Point-by-Point Response: Provide a detailed rebuttal addressing each reviewer comment; Clearly indicate where modifications were made in the revised manuscript
— Cover Letter: Summarize key revisions; Include any additional information requested by the editorial team
Please submit your revised materials through the submission link provided in the decision email (do not create a new submission). Failure to follow these instructions may delay the review process.
Online first
Accepted articles will be published online immediately upon receipt of the final revised manuscript. This constitutes the official first publication, which is fully citable using the assigned DOI. Following the release of the complete journal issue, the article may also be cited using traditional volume, issue, and page number references.
Proofreading
The proofreading stage is strictly for verifying typesetting accuracy, text completeness, proper formatting of tables and figures, and so on. Please note that substantive content modifications (including but not limited to new results, data corrections, title changes, or authorship alterations) require explicit approval from either the Editor-in-Chief or Area Editor.
Language editing service
To support non-native English speakers, Acta Electronica Sinica offers professional language editing services for manuscript content in English. This service ensures research is presented with optimal clarity and precision.*
*This service requires payment by the author(s). Pricing is determined by the content's word count and the requested turnaround time.
Acta Electronica Sinica is published under the subscription model. The journal retains copyright for all published articles. Accepted manuscripts will be published online promptly upon completion of the editorial process.
Each article published on the journal should provide the License to Publish. The License to Publish should be signed and uploaded to the submission system.
Electronic signatures are permitted.
For any material (including figures, tables, or other content) where authors do not hold copyright, written permission for reuse must be obtained and submitted with the manuscript. Proper attribution to the original source is required.
Appeals and Reconsideration Requests
Authors may submit an appeal or request for reconsideration of a final editorial decision by emailing new@ejournal.org.cn. The request must be submitted by the corresponding author, with a mandatory courtesy copy to all co-authors. All listed authors must agree to the request before it is considered by the editorial board. The request must be addressed to the EIC and includes a detailed justification for reconsideration and any supporting evidence or additional information.
Manuscript Withdrawal Requests
To withdraw a manuscript from consideration, authors must submit a formal request to new@ejournal.org.cn, including Manuscript ID and corresponding author’s name. All co-authors must consent to the withdrawal. The request must be sent by the corresponding author, with a mandatory courtesy copy to all co-authors. While optional, authors are encouraged to provide a reason for withdrawal.

